Leadership

The Probation Conversation Before January 2027

A manager and a new team member in a one-to-one conversation at a table
Quick answer

From 1 January 2027, protection from unfair dismissal starts after six months of service instead of two years, and the cap on the compensatory award is removed. For most managers this changes less about dismissals than about the months before them. The conversation that names a performance problem early, plainly and fairly becomes the one that matters, and it is the one that is easiest to put off.

What changes on 1 January 2027

The government's timeline lists for 1 January 2027 a "reduction of unfair dismissal qualifying period to 6 months, for dismissals from 1 January 2027, and uncapping compensatory awards". Today the Employment Rights Act 1996 sets the qualifying period at not less than two years (section 108).

Acas spells out what this does and does not mean. Someone who already has at least six months' service on 1 January 2027 will be protected. There is still no legal requirement to have a probation period, and the Act does not change them.

Employers might want probation to end before protection starts, but Acas is clear that "this does not avoid legal risks", because protections such as those against discrimination and for whistleblowers apply from the first day. And protection is not a bar: "Employers can still dismiss employees fairly after 6 months of employment."

Why the conversation moves forward

Under a two-year qualifying period, a manager could leave an uncomfortable conversation for months and still have room. Under six months there is little room left. A first honest conversation in month five, about a problem that was visible in month two, gives the new starter almost no time to change and gives the manager almost nothing to point to.

Acas describes what a good probation review looks like, and most of it is behaviour. Managers should "be honest about an employee's performance", explain things clearly, keep records and make it a two-way conversation. One of the reasons it gives for regular reviews is to "make sure the probation outcome is not a surprise to the employee". None of that is hard to understand. All of it is hard to do across a table from someone who is trying, likeable and not yet good enough.

The test for any probation review: if the outcome would come as a surprise to the new starter, the important conversation has not happened yet.

How we rehearse it

One of the short scenes on our How we work page is close to this conversation. You are Alex, a team lead. Sam is talented, popular, and has just missed a client deadline for the third time. You need to talk. In a workshop, a professional actor would play Sam, and respond the way Sam might: with a reason, a deflection, sometimes a hurt silence.

The scene runs on our signature tool, Rewind. Rewire. Restart. Rewind goes back to the moment the conversation turned, which can be the very first sentence, if the problem was softened until it disappeared. Rewire asks for one specific change: a question instead of a verdict, a pause instead of a reply, a new angle instead of the old one.

Restart plays the moment again, with Sam pushing back as before, so the manager feels what the clearer version is like to say and to hear. The same structure carries into our new manager training and difficult conversations programmes.

Ninety days later

Whether the first honest conversation happens early is decided in ordinary weeks, long before the review date, so a single day of practice may not be enough on its own. Around 90 days after a programme, participants can take an optional follow-up simulation: one hour over Zoom, a fresh scenario and a coach they have not met, so there is nothing to rehearse from memory. It is a second go with feedback, not an assessment.

Training has limits here, and they are worth stating. It does not replace legal advice or a fair procedure, it cannot decide whether a dismissal is fair, and it cannot make a role the right fit. What it can do is let a manager try the early, honest conversation before having it for real.

The Probation Conversation Before January 2027: The Takeaways

From 1 January 2027, protection from unfair dismissal starts after six months instead of two years, and the cap on compensatory awards is removed. That moves the important conversation forward: the early, honest probation review becomes the step that matters most.

Acas's guidance on reviews is largely behavioural, from being honest about performance to making sure the outcome is not a surprise. That is the kind of conversation that can be rehearsed with an actor, using Rewind, Rewire, Restart, and practised again in a follow-up simulation. Training does not replace legal advice or a fair procedure.

  • From 1 January 2027 the unfair dismissal qualifying period falls from two years to six months, for dismissals from that date, and the cap on compensatory awards is removed (gov.uk timeline, updated 5 November 2026).
  • Acas: probation periods are not affected by the Employment Rights Act 2025, ending probation before six months "does not avoid legal risks", and fair dismissal remains possible after six months.
  • Acas guidance on reviews is behavioural: be honest about performance, explain clearly, keep records, make it two-way, and make sure the outcome is not a surprise.
  • A rehearsed scene with an actor practises the first honest sentence; a follow-up simulation around 90 days later gives a second go. Training does not replace legal advice or a fair procedure.

Frequently Asked Questions

When does the six-month unfair dismissal rule start?

For dismissals from 1 January 2027, according to the government's Employment Rights Act timeline (updated 5 November 2026). Acas adds that someone who already has at least six months' service on 1 January 2027 is protected from that date.

Does the Employment Rights Act 2025 change probation periods?

No. Acas says the Act does not affect probation periods: there is still no legal requirement to have one, and they can be any length. Ending probation before six months does not avoid legal risks, because other protections apply from day one.

Can managers practise probation reviews?

Yes. A probation review is a conversation, and its hardest moment, naming a performance problem clearly, can be rehearsed with a professional actor who responds as the new starter would. It does not replace legal advice or a fair procedure.

Sources: Department for Business and Trade, Plan to Make Work Pay and Employment Rights Act: timeline update (updated 5 November 2026) · Employment Rights Act 1996, section 108 · Acas, Probation periods · Acas, Probation reviews · Sidestream, How we work

Continue Reading

Related Articles

Communication

How to Handle Difficult Conversations at Work

Behaviour Change

Why Manager Training Fails to Change Behaviour

Leadership & Pipeline

The Quiet Refusal: Why Younger Workers Are Saying No To Management

Sidestream

Take Action

Bring Us Your
People Problem

Free 30-minute diagnostic call. No deck, no hard sell, just an honest conversation about whether we can help.